a special edition of LaborUpFront. The
goal of LaborUpfront is to provide members and friends with news,
information, and general ways to stay connected with the on-going
struggles of workers. You can also visit us at our
for further information on the stories in this newsletter and much
more! E-mail email@example.com to
join the list.
Scott Marshall, Labor Commission Chair
Melissa O’Rourke, Labor Commission Coordinator, Labor UpFront editor
Buffenbarger election speech could strip gears of labor unity
By Scott Marshall
Getting carried away with your own rhetoric is rarely a good thing. Tom
Buffenbarger, president of the Machinists’ union (International
Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers), did just that in a
“warm-up” speech for Hillary Clinton the night of the Wisconsin primary
win by Barack Obama. (Necessary disclaimer: I have great respect for
the Machinists’ union and president Buffenbarger, a tough industrial
union that goes up against some of the biggest multinationals. So this
incident is all the more worrisome from a seasoned labor leader.)
Ironically Buffenbarger’s main point was to ridicule Obama’s oratory.
John McCain made a nasty attack on Obama’s speech-making that same
night, but Buffenbarger’s was even more mean-spirited.
In the first place it’s ironic that a labor leader should ridicule good
oratory. The history of the labor movement is replete with labor
leaders who inspired and moved workers to action with their ability to
put into words the hopes, aspirations and demands of those who dream of
a better life and a better world for working people.
Eugene Debs spoke eloquently of an industrial union for rail workers.
One of his most famous speeches called for an end to workers dying in
WWI as cannon fodder for the narrow interests of the industrialists and
capitalists. He brought millions into the labor movement and got
millions of votes on the Socialist Party ticket with his inspiring
The soaring street corner oratory of A. Phillip Randolph inspired
thousands of African American rail workers to join the Brotherhood of
Sleeping Car Porters and fight for their dreams. His words inspired
millions to fight for civil rights and to link civil and labor rights
together in one struggle for all working people.
And then there was John L. Lewis with his fiery call for organizing the
Committee of Industrial Organizations, the CIO.
Besides the unfairness and shallowness of this attack on Obama,
Buffenbarger’s speech also rudely, and with rightwing stereotypes,
attacked Obama’s supporters. Ridiculing supporters as “latte-drinking,
Prius-driving, Birkenstock-wearing, trust fund babies” ignores the
large number of union members and their families, of all races and
nationalities, who are supporting Obama. Not to mention that I know
lots of steelworkers who appreciate a good latte now and again, and who
would like to drive a hybrid car to save gas and the environment.
Working people sorely need to defeat John McCain in November. That can
only be done with the full support and unity of all the labor movement.
No matter who wins the Democratic nomination, there will be millions of
labor households who were once supporting the other candidate.
Contrast Buffenbarger’s speech to what the AFL-CIO is saying about the
elections. The AFL-CIO plans to spend $54 million, $6 million more than
in the 2004 election, in support of the Democratic candidate for
president, no matter who wins the nomination, and in dozens of
congressional races. In the meantime, the AFL-CIO, the Change to Win
federation, and most of labor are busy exposing the anti-labor,
anti-working people record of John McCain. They are building an army of
labor activists for the general election.
Most of those in the labor movement, both AFL-CIO and Change to Win
unions, who have endorsed a candidate for the Democratic nomination are
campaigning positively on the strengths of their chosen candidate. Most
recognize that all of both Clinton’s and Obama’s supporters in labor
are vital sections of the democratic coalition that it will take to end
corporate, rightwing domination of our political life.
Buffenbarger should wonder why his speech got picked up far and wide in
To remove your name from our mailing list, please e-mail firstname.lastname@example.org
We’re welcoming questions, comments and stories for our next
newsletter. Send them to us at email@example.com
or call (773)
446-9920, ext. 212.